Can You Really Eat Too Many Vegetables?

When you think of healthy eating, no doubt one of the first images that springs to mind is plates piled high with leafy greens and cruciferous clusters, with maybe the odd carrot, beet, or tomato* adding a splash of color. While vegetables are a critical component of a balanced diet, consuming too many can have potential consequences. So is it possible to have too much of a good thing?

Short answer? Yes. Long answer? Read on.

1. Digestive problems from all that fiber.

According to the Mayo Clinic, women should try to eat at least 21-25 grams of fiber a day, while men should aim for 30-38 grams a day. The average cup of vegetables contains 8 grams of fiber, which means 4-5 cups will put you over the bar. To put this in perspective, a small bowl typically holds about 3-4 cups.

Now bear in mind, this guideline from the Mayo Clinic is a suggested intake, not a maximum. Most people eat more fiber than recommended without suffering any negative consequences. The problem strikes when you eat more than your stomach can handle. At the very least, you end up suffering the unpleasant side effects of digestive distress, gas, bloating, and severe constipation.

Although fiber is known to promote regular bowel movements, when consumed in excess, it can actually cause a slowdown in digestion, leading to infrequent, hard stools.

Another negative effect of excessive fiber consumption is indigestion. When the digestive system is overwhelmed with large amounts of fiber, it may struggle to properly break them down, leading to discomfort, stomach pain, and even diarrhea.

Gas and vegetable bloating are the most common side effects of eating too many vegetables.  Certain fibrous vegetables, especially those high in FODMAPs (fermentable oligosaccharides, disaccharides, monosaccharides, and polyols), can contribute to bloating and digestive discomfort in individuals with poor gut health. This is because fiber isn't completely broken down by the digestive enzymes in the small intestine, and instead begins to ferment because of the gut bacteria in the large intestine. This fermentation process produces gas as a byproduct, causing uncomfortable bloating and flatulence.

High-FODMAP veggies that can cause bloating include:

• Broccoli
• Onions
• Garlic
• Sprouts
• Cauliflower

To reduce vegetable bloating, it is recommended to lower intake of raw vegetables and cruciferous vegetables, as cooking these vegetables can help break down some of the fibrous components and make them easier to digest. Additionally, opting for low-FODMAP vegetables, such as leafy greens, can help prevent excessive gas and bloating.

Though fiber is an important part of a healthy diet, excessive consumption can lead to digestive problems. But by avoiding specific vegetables and implementing prevention tips, you can prevent these issues and promote regular bowel movements.

2. Kidney problems from certain veggies.

Certain vegetables can potentially cause kidney problems if consumed in excess or by people with pre-existing kidney conditions. These vegetables often contain high levels of certain compounds that can negatively affect the kidneys.

Spinach is one of these vegetables. Although it's highly nutritious and loaded with vitamins and minerals, it is also rich in oxalic acid. This compound can combine with calcium in the urine to create crystals. Over time, these crystals can accumulate and form kidney stones.

Another vegetable that may cause kidney complications is beetroot. Beetroots have numerous health benefits, but consuming too much can cause a temporary condition called beeturia, where the urine appears reddish or pinkish. While this is generally harmless, it can cause unnecessary anxiety for those unaware of this side effect.

Overeating potassium-rich vegetables like avocados and tomatoes, can also result in kidney complications. For folks with kidney disease or reduced kidney function, a high-potassium diet can lead to irregular heart rhythms and even cardiac arrest. It is crucial for those at risk of kidney disease to closely monitor their potassium intake and work with healthcare providers to determine safe limits.

Phosphorus-rich vegetables, like broccoli and Brussels sprouts, can be problematic for individuals with kidney disease as well. Excess dietary phosphorus can disrupt the delicate balance of phosphorus and calcium in the body, leading to weakened bones (osteoporosis) and other complications.

While vegetables are generally beneficial for kidney health, some varieties can cause problems when consumed excessively or by individuals with kidney conditions. It is vital to maintain a balanced diet and consult healthcare professionals to prevent any complications or adverse effects on kidney function.

3. Nutrient deficiencies.

Overeating vegetables can potentially lead to other nutrient deficiencies. While your stomach is struggling with all those vegetables, it won’t be able to absorb nutrients from the other foods you’re eating. You know how taking a whole bunch of multivitamins doesn’t fill you up with nutrients? Same thing with eating too many vegetables. Once you reach a certain threshold, your body will simply stop processing the nutrients you’re putting into it. Fiber can bind to certain minerals, such as iron, calcium, and zinc, reducing their absorption in the body. This can impair overall nutrient availability and potentially lead to deficiencies over time. So too many vegetables could actually end up making your other food less healthy.

While vegetables are rich in many vitamins and minerals, they may not provide sufficient amounts of protein or healthy fats. Protein deficiency can occur if you rely heavily on vegetables and do not consume enough protein-rich foods such as meat, fish, or beans. This can lead to muscle loss, weakness, fatigue, and compromised immune function. Similarly, a vegetable-dense diet may lack healthy fats, which are crucial for proper brain function, hormone production, and nutrient absorption.

A vegetable-dense diet can also affect vitamin D levels. Vitamin D is primarily obtained through sun exposure and dairy products. Since vegetables do not contain much vitamin D, people who rely heavily on a vegetable-rich diet may have lower levels of Vitamin D. To address this issue, it is advisable to include vitamin D-rich foods in the diet such as fatty fish, eggs, and fortified foods like milk alternatives. Additionally, spending some time in the sun can help the body produce vitamin D naturally.

It is important to note that while vegetables are packed with beneficial nutrients, they also contain antinutrients. These compounds can interfere with the absorption or utilization of certain nutrients, such as iron and calcium. However, cooking vegetables or pairing them with foods rich in vitamin C can help reduce the effects of antinutrients and enhance nutrient absorption.

So three to four servings of vegetables will provide you with the nutrients you need. Any more than that, and you’re getting a diminishing return.

4. Unintentional weight loss or weight gain.

Consuming an imbalanced diet consisting mainly of vegetables can also lead to weight imbalance, either weight loss or weight gain due to imbalances in nutrient intake.

Unintentional weight loss can occur due to the high fiber content present in most vegetables. Fiber adds bulk to the diet, resulting in a feeling of fullness. As a result, you may consume fewer overall calories, leading to unintentional weight loss. The high fiber content in non starchy vegetables also aids in digestion and promotes regular bowel movements, which can further contribute to weight loss.

On the other hand, certain vegetables, especially starchy ones like potatoes, corn, and peas, can contribute to weight gain. These vegetables have higher calorie counts compared to non-starchy vegetables. Consuming them in large quantities can lead to an excessive calorie intake that causes weight gain. It's important to note that although these starchy vegetables are nutritious, they should be eaten in moderation as part of a well-balanced diet.

Stuffing yourself with veggies is certainly a great way to feel full while minimizing your caloric intake. But it’s not really a healthy strategy in the long run. Your body needs protein, fats, and carbohydrates to stay healthy, so it’s important to leave room for them.

5. You could turn yourself orange.

Carotenemia, also known as carotene pigmentation, is a condition characterized by the skin turning orange or yellowish due to excessive intake of beta-carotene. Beta-carotene is a type of carotenoid, a pigment responsible for the orange, yellow, and green colors found in many fruits and vegetables. It is a precursor to vitamin A and is converted into this essential nutrient in the body.

When beta-carotene-rich foods are consumed - such as carrots, spinach, kale, tomatoes, yams, and winter squash - the body absorbs the beta-carotene molecules from these foods. The beta-carotene is then converted into vitamin A through a series of enzymatic reactions. Once converted, vitamin A is stored in the fatty tissues under the skin, contributing to its characteristic coloration.

Admittedly, this problem is minor compared to the others on the list. Beta-carotene in proper amounts, can actually help keep your eyes healthy. However, if you eat too much, the carotenoids will get circulated through your bloodstream and end up discoloring your skin. The effect is only temporary and it’s not actually dangerous. However, when you’re already dealing with digestive distress and improper nutrition, turning yourself orange is simply a headache you don’t need.

To prevent or reduce the risk of skin discoloration caused by carotenemia, moderate your intake of carotenoid-rich foods by including a variety of fruits, vegetables, and other food groups into your diet.

Conclusion

So what’s the takeaway here? Consuming vegetables is crucial for maintaining a healthy body as they offer numerous benefits. Vegetables are good for you and you should definitely make sure you’re eating *at least* the daily recommended amount. However, eating too many vegetables will diminish their nutritional benefit and will likely lead to issues ranging from the embarrassing to the downright harmful. As with any dietary choice, it’s important to show some restraint and common sense to ensure your body is getting everything it needs.

------------

*Yes, we know tomatoes are technically fruits, not vegetables. Don’t be that guy.

Resources

"High-Fiber Foods", by the Mayo Clinic
"Beeturia", by the NIH National Center for Biotechnology Information
"How to Reduce Antinutrients in Foods", by Healthline